As a sophomore, O’Shea was third behind teammates Kenzie Carle and Millie Cluxton with 37 points in the Girls Greater Catholic League. In the postseason, however, O’Shea had the game-winning goal against Mount Notre Dame in the regional finals and had another game-winning goal in the state semifinals against Olentangy Orange.
The senior midfielder was a second-team All-Ohio selection for the Division I state champion Saints. She tied her teammate, Kenzie Carle, at the top of the conference with 40 points in a season with 13 goals and 14 assists in 2022. She was first-team All-Girls Greater Catholic League and has committed to the University of Charleston.
A junior last year, Carle tied her teammate, Millie Cluxton, in the Girls Greater Catholic League in points with 40. Carle scored 14 goals with 12 assists in 22 games played for the Division I state champion Saints. She was first-team All-GGCL and will play at Bellarmine.